Edinburgh - 0131 228 2083
Glasgow - 0141 248 6552

McGill & Co is a Scottish immigration law firm specialising in UK immigration, nationality and refugee law.

Article 8 cases outwith the Rules

12 June 2013 McGill & Co Solicitors Immigration

Last week we posted about the Scottish case from the Court of Session, PS V SSHD, [2013] CSOH 59, which came out in April and which helpfully confirmed that there required to be a two stage process in Article 8 cases, a consideration under the Rules first of all but then a separate and independent scrutiny of the Article 8 argument. We now have a decision from the Inner House , MS V SSHD CSIH [2013] 52, which takes us into new territory of a good arguable case : " Before it is necessary to embark on that second‑stage exercise, however, the application for leave to enter or remain must demonstrate a good arguable case that leave should be granted outside the rules: that a distinct assessment of proportionality should be made to determine whether removal would infringe the applicant's article 8 rights. If that is not demonstrated, it can be assumed that the applicant's article 8 rights will be adequately dealt with by applying the new rules. Finally, the test of exceptionality should not be used any longer; instead, decision‑makers should focus on the question of whether the applicant has shown a good arguable case that his or her application should be dealt with outside the rules."


Call now


Average rating for Our Testimonials, McGill & Co is 5 Star of 5 stars - based on 84 Review

Make an enquiry

Please let us know your name.
Please let us know your email address.
Please enter a valid phone number
Please let us know the nature of your enquiry
Please let us know your message.
How did you hear about us?

Please tell us your preferred office

Invalid Input

Latest Tweets